Insights from Peter St. Cyr's reporter notebook.
I also don't understand why the Catholic Church is in on writing legislation. But since the Church is apparently "negotiating" with unknown individuals who are supposedly representing my interests as a gay woman in the process, why aren't other churches and religious organizations that support GLBT rights included in the discussions? Regarding Sen. Sanchez's comment that passage of a domestic partnership bill is mostly a matter of educating people about the facts about the bill, I hope he will be one of those who helps do just that by engaging his colleagues and others he knows to educate and advocate on the issue.
It is a mistake to say that the Constitution specifies "separation of church and state" without understanding what the document actually says and without knowing the intention of the people who wrote it.Separation of church and state is a metaphor Thomas Jefferson used to explain one part of the First Amendment. It was not intended to illustrate the whole amendment. The University of Virginia has collected Jefferson's writings. In the section where Jefferson explains the need for the First Amendment you can find the phrase "freedom of religion" six times, but you will not find the phrase "separation of church and state" even once. (churchvstate.blogspot.com/2008/11/thomas-jefferson-meaning-of-bill-of.html)So keep the argument to the more logical concepts brought up by both sides. The Constitution does not prohibit people from using their personal morality to make decisions. How else would they make many of the decisions we are faced with?
Post a Comment
2 comments:
I also don't understand why the Catholic Church is in on writing legislation. But since the Church is apparently "negotiating" with unknown individuals who are supposedly representing my interests as a gay woman in the process, why aren't other churches and religious organizations that support GLBT rights included in the discussions?
Regarding Sen. Sanchez's comment that passage of a domestic partnership bill is mostly a matter of educating people about the facts about the bill, I hope he will be one of those who helps do just that by engaging his colleagues and others he knows to educate and advocate on the issue.
It is a mistake to say that the Constitution specifies "separation of church and state" without understanding what the document actually says and without knowing the intention of the people who wrote it.
Separation of church and state is a metaphor Thomas Jefferson used to explain one part of the First Amendment. It was not intended to illustrate the whole amendment. The University of Virginia has collected Jefferson's writings. In the section where Jefferson explains the need for the First Amendment you can find the phrase "freedom of religion" six times, but you will not find the phrase "separation of church and state" even once. (churchvstate.blogspot.com/2008/11/thomas-jefferson-meaning-of-bill-of.html)
So keep the argument to the more logical concepts brought up by both sides. The Constitution does not prohibit people from using their personal morality to make decisions. How else would they make many of the decisions we are faced with?
Post a Comment